This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting Wander Well Co.!

Thanksgiving is one of my favorite holidays — the whole point is gathering around a table full of food you love. But if you’re trying to stay on track with your health goals (or just want to feel a little less sluggish after dinner), a few simple swaps can make a big difference without sacrificing any of the comfort or flavor you look forward to all year.

Here are my go-to healthy swaps for classic Thanksgiving dishes, plus the products I actually use to make them easy.

Mashed Potatoes: Swap Heavy Cream for Greek Yogurt

Classic mashed potatoes lean on butter and heavy cream for that rich, creamy texture — but plain Greek yogurt gives you the same creaminess with way more protein and less saturated fat. Add a little roasted garlic and you won’t miss the cream at all.

What I use: My favorite Greek Yogurt and potato masher that is really one of the most underrated kitchen tools! 

Green Bean Casserole: Swap Canned Soup for a Homemade Base

The traditional canned cream-of-mushroom base is loaded with sodium and preservatives. A quick homemade version using sautéed mushrooms, a splash of broth, and a bit of arrowroot or flour to thicken gives you the same cozy flavor with ingredients you can actually pronounce.

What I use: Love this bone broth to add protein to the dish! But feel free to use any type of broth you like. This is one of my favorite brands for cast iron cookware. This dish in particular is great for a casserole. 

Stuffing: Swap White Bread for Whole Grain or Cauliflower

Whole grain bread adds fiber and keeps you fuller longer, and if you want to cut carbs further, a cauliflower-based stuffing holds up surprisingly well with the right seasoning blend (sage, thyme, and rosemary are non-negotiable in my house).

What I use: Kinders has great seasoning options for all your cooking needs but this one in particular is great for stuffing. This mixing bowl set from Walmart is great because it has multiple sizes AND lids (great for storing!). 

Cranberry Sauce: Swap White Sugar for Maple Syrup or Orange Juice

Canned cranberry sauce is basically candy in a can. Making your own with fresh or frozen cranberries, a natural sweetener like maple syrup, and a little orange zest gives you way more control over the sugar content — and it tastes brighter, too.

What I use: When looking for maple syrup you don’t want added sugars. This one (one again from Walmart!) is great and single ingredient. This saucepan is a great size for making a sauce! 

Gravy: Swap Pan Drippings + Flour for a Lighter Broth-Based Version

Traditional gravy is delicious but heavy. A lighter version made with low-sodium broth, a touch of the drippings for flavor, and a cornstarch slurry to thicken gives you nearly the same richness with a fraction of the fat.

What I use: I love this tool instead of a gravy boat for managing serving sizes. 

Pie: Swap Refined Sugar for Coconut Sugar or Dates

For pumpkin or sweet potato pie, coconut sugar swaps in 1:1 for white sugar with a lower glycemic impact, and it adds a subtle caramel note that pairs beautifully with warm spices. Date paste works well too if you want to cut refined sugar out almost entirely.

What I use: I have recently been using more coconut sugar and really like the taste! And of course if you don’t have a pie dish, it’s a staple item in the kitchen. 

The Bottom Line

You don’t have to overhaul your entire Thanksgiving spread to eat a little lighter this year. Pick one or two of these swaps that sound realistic for your table, and build from there. The goal isn’t a “perfect” holiday plate — it’s one that still feels like Thanksgiving, just with ingredients that leave you feeling good afterward too.

Which swap are you trying first this year? I’d love to hear in the comments!

---

Looking for more ways to stay healthy through the holidays? Check out [Best Supplements Heading Into Fall] and [How to Create a Cozy Morning Routine for Cooler Mornings] for more seasonal wellness tips.